- 11/24/2018 - Off-Broadway - Matinee - midnightlosemymind’s master - Dove Cameron (Cher), Dave Thomas Brown (as Josh), Zurin Villanueva (Dionne), Gilbert L. Bailey II (Murray), Danielle Marie Gonzalez (Lucy), Ephie Aardema (Tai), Will Connolly (Travis), Lori Alan (Miss Geist/Ms. Stoeger), Chris Hoch (Mel/Mr. Hall/DMV Instructor), Tessa Grady (Amber), Brett Thiele (Elton), Sara Andreas (Heather), L’ogan J’ones (Max), Darius Jordan Lee (Sean), Justin Mortelliti (Christian), Talya Groves (Summer)
- 11/24/2018 - Off-Broadway - Evening - Dove Cameron (Cher Horowitz), Dave Thomas Brown (Josh), Ephie Aardema (Tai), Zurin Villanueva (Dionne), Lori Alan (Miss Geist/Ms. Stoeger), Sara Andreas (Heather), Gilbert L. Bailey II (Murray), Will Connolly (Travis), Danielle Marie Gonzalez (Lucy), Tessa Grady (Amber), L’ogan J’ones (Max), Chris Hoch (Mel, others), Darius Jordan Lee (Sean), Justin Mortelliti (Christian), Tiffany Engen, Katie Goffman, Talya Groves, Jeff Kuhr and Brett Thiele.
- 11/27/2018 - Off-Broadway - brookeslohst’s master - Dove Cameron, Dave Thomas Brown, Zurin Villanueva, Gilbert L. Bailey II, Danielle Marie Gonzalez, Ephie Aardema, Will Connolly, Lori Alan, Chris Hoch, Tessa Grady, Brett Thiele, Sara Andreas, L’ogan J’ones, Darius Jordan Lee, Justin Mortelliti, Talya Groves. NFT until 02/13/2019
- 12/01/2018 - Off-Broadway - Matinee - Dove Cameron (Cher - Act 1), Katie Goffman (u/s Cher - Act 2), Ephie Aardema (Tai), Sara Andreas (Heather), Gilbert L. Bailey II (Murray), Dave Thomas Brown (Josh), Will Connolly (Travis), Danielle Marie Gonzalez (Lucy), Tessa Grady (Amber), Talya Groves (Summer), Chris Hoch (Mel/Mr. Hall/DMV Instructor), L'ogan J'ones (Max), Darius Jordan Lee (Sean), Justin Mortelliti (Christian), Megan Sikora (Miss Geist/Ms. Stoeger), Brett Thiele (Elton), and Zurin Villanueva (Dionne). Notes: Dove Cameron called out mid-show, and her understudy performed after intermission.
- 12/07/2018 - Off-Broadway - Evening - Dove Cameron (Cher), Zurin Villanueva (Dionne), Dave Thomas Brown (Josh), Ephie Aardema (Tai), Gilbert L. Bailey II (Murray), Will Connolly (Travis), Chris Hoch (Mel/Mr. Hall/DMV Guy), Megan Sikora (Miss Geist/Ms. Stoeger), Justin Mortelliti (Christian), Tessa Grady (Amber), Brett Thiele (Elton). Ensemble: Sara Andreas, Danielle Marie Gonzalez, Talya Groves, L'ogan J'ones, Darius Jordan Lee.
- 12/09/2018 - Off-Broadway - Dove Cameron (Cher), Zurin Villanueva (Dionne), Dave Thomas Brown (Josh), Ephie Aardema (Tai), Gilbert L. Bailey II (Murray), Will Connolly (Travis), Chris Hoch (Mel/Mr. Hall/DMV Guy), Megan Sikora (Miss Geist/Ms. Stoeger), Justin Mortelliti (Christian), Tessa Grady (Amber), Brett Thiele (Elton). Sara Andreas, Danielle Marie Gonzalez, Talya Groves, L'ogan J'ones, Darius Jordan Lee.
- 12/15/2018 - Off-Broadway - bubbledress’ master - Katie Goffman (u/s Cher Horowitz), Zurin Villanueva (Dionne Davenport), Ephie Aardema (Tai Frasier), Dave Thomas Brown (Josh Lucas), Chris Hoch (Mel Horowitz / Alphonse Hall / DMV Instructor), Tessa Grady (Amber Mariens), Justin Mortelliti (Christian Stovitz), Megan Sikora (Miss Geist / Millie Stoeger), Gilbert L. Bailey II (Murray Duvall), Will Connolly (Travis Birkenstock), Brett Thiele (Elton Tiscia), Talya Groves (Summer), Darius Jordan Lee (Sean Holliday)
- 01/02/2019 - Off-Broadway - Matinee - myroadofgoodintentions’ master - Ephie Aardema (Tai), Katie Goffman (u/s Cher), Zurin Villanueva (Dionne), Dave Thomas Brown (Josh), Justin Mortelliti (Christian), Will Connolly (Travis), Megan Sikora (Miss Geist/Ms. Stoeger), Tessa Grady (Amber), Chris Hoch ( Mel/Mr. Hall/DMV Instructor)
- 01/04/2019 - Off-Broadway - starcuffedjeans’ master - Katie Goffman (u/s Cher), Dave Thomas Brown (Josh), Ephie Aardema (Tai), Zurin Villanueva (Dionne), Lori Alan (Miss Geist/Ms. Stoeger), Sara Andreas (Heather), Gilbert L. Bailey II (Murray), Will Connolly (Travis), Tiffany Engen (u/s Lucy), Tessa Grady (Amber), L'ogan J'ones (Max), Chris Hoch (Mel/Ensemble), Darius Jordan Lee (Sean), Justin Mortelliti (Christian)
- 01/10/2019 - Off-Broadway - tjonc’s master - Dove Cameron (Cher), Zurin Villanueva (Dionne), Dave Thomas Brown (Josh), Ephie Aardema (Tai), Gilbert L. Bailey II (Murray), Will Connolly (Travis), Jeff Kuhr (u/s Mel/Mr. Hall/DMV Guy), Megan Sikora (Miss Geist/Ms. Stoeger), Justin Mortelliti (Christian), Tessa Grady (Amber), Brett Thiele (Elton). Ensemble: Sara Andreas, Danielle Marie Gonzalez, Talya Groves, L'ogan J'ones, Darius Jordan Lee.
- 01/11/2019 - Off-Broadway - Katie Goffman (u/s Cher), Dave Thomas Brown (Josh), Ephie Aardema (Tai), Zurin Villanueva (Dionne), Lori Alan (Miss Geist/Ms. Stoeger), Sara Andreas (Heather), Gilbert L. Bailey II (Murray), Will Connolly (Travis), Danielle Marie Gonzalez (Lucy), Tessa Grady (Amber), L'ogan J'ones (Max), Chris Hoch (Mel/Ensemble), Darius Jordan Lee (Sean), Justin Mortelliti (Christian).
- 01/12/2019 - Off-Broadway - Katie Goffman (u/s Cher), Dave Thomas Brown (Josh), Ephie Aardema (Tai), Zurin Villanueva (Dionne), Lori Alan (Miss Geist/Ms. Stoeger), Sara Andreas (Heather), Gilbert L. Bailey II (Murray), Will Connolly (Travis), Danielle Marie Gonzalez (Lucy), Tessa Grady (Amber), L'ogan J'ones (Max), Chris Hoch (Mel/Ensemble), Darius Jordan Lee (Sean), Justin Mortelliti (Christian). Notes: Closing night!