- 07/26/2018 - Off-Broadway - today4utomorrow4netflix’s master - Will Roland (Jeremy), George Salazar (Michael), Gerard Canonico (Rich), Jason Tam (The Squip), Stephanie Hsu (Christine), Katlyn Carlson (Chloe), Tiffany Mann (Jenna), Lauren Marcus (Brooke), Jason Sweetooth Williams (Mr. Reyes/Jeremy's Dad). Notes: 1st Preview!
- 07/29/2018 - Off-Broadway - starcuffedjeans’ master - Will Roland (Jeremy), George Salazar (Michael), Gerard Canonico (Rich), Jason Tam (The Squip), Stephanie Hsu (Christine), Katlyn Carlson (Chloe), Tiffany Mann (Jenna), Lauren Marcus (Brooke), Jason Sweetooth Williams (Mr. Reyes/Jeremy's Dad)
- 08/12/2018 - Off-Broadway - Matinee - brookeslohst’s master - Will Roland (Jeremy), George Salazar (Michael), Gerard Canonico (Rich), Jason Tam (The Squip), Stephanie Hsu (Christine), Katlyn Carlson (Chloe), Tiffany Mann (Jenna), Lauren Marcus (Brooke), Jason Sweetooth Williams (Mr. Reyes/Jeremy's Dad).
- 08/18/2018 - Off-Broadway - Matinee - brookeslohst’s master - Will Roland (Jeremy), George Salazar (Michael), Gerard Canonico (Rich), Jason Tam (The Squip), Stephanie Hsu (Christine), Katlyn Carlson (Chloe), Tiffany Mann (Jenna), Lauren Marcus (Brooke), Jason Sweetooth Williams (Mr. Reyes/Jeremy's Dad), Troy Iwata (u/s Jake).
- 08/25/2018 - Off-Broadway - Matinee - brookeslohst’s master - Will Roland (Jeremy), George Salazar (Michael), Gerard Canonico (Rich), Jason Tam (The Squip), Stephanie Hsu (Christine), Katlyn Carlson (Chloe), Tiffany Mann (Jenna), Lauren Marcus (Brooke), Jason Sweetooth Williams (Mr. Reyes/Jeremy's Dad)
- 08/25/2018 - Off-Broadway - Matinee - Will Roland, George Salazar, Cameron Bond, Gerard Canonico, Katlyn Carlson, Stephanie Hsu, Troy Iwata, Tiffany Mann, Lauren Marcus, Britton Smith, Talia Suskauer, Jason Tam, Jason SweetTooth Williams
- 08/28/2018 - Off-Broadway - saltylemontrades’ master - Gerard Canonico (Rich Goranski), Katlyn Carson (Chloe Valentine), Stephanie Hsu (Christine Canigula), Tiffany Mann (Jenna Rolan), Lauren Marcus (Brooke Lohst), Will Roland (Jeremey Heere), George Salazar (Michael Mell), Britton Smith (Jake Dillinger), Jason Tam (The Squip), Jason Sweettooth Williams (Jeremy's Dad/Mr. Reyes/Scary Stockboy). Notes: Taken from the front row. Some comments can be heard from my friend and very loud laughter can also be heard from a presumably drunk man behind me.
- 09/01/2018 - Off-Broadway - Matinee - brookeslohst’s master - Will Roland (Jeremy), George Salazar (Michael), Gerard Canonico (Rich), Jason Tam (The Squip), Stephanie Hsu (Christine), Katlyn Carlson (Chloe), Tiffany Mann (Jenna), Talia Suskauer (u/s Brooke), Jason Sweetooth Williams (Mr. Reyes/Jeremy's Dad).
- 09/05/2018 - Off-Broadway - brookeslohst’s master - Will Roland (Jeremy), George Salazar (Michael), Gerard Canonico (Rich), Jason Tam (The Squip), Stephanie Hsu (Christine), Katlyn Carlson (Chloe), Tiffany Mann (Jenna), Talia Suskauer (u/s Brooke), Jason Sweetooth Williams (Mr. Reyes/Jeremy's Dad).
- 09/18/2018 - Off Broadway - tjonc’s master - Will Roland (Jeremy), George Salazar (Michael), Gerard Canonico (Rich), Jason Tam (The Squip), Stephanie Hsu (Christine), Katlyn Carlson (Chloe), Tiffany Mann (Jenna), Lauren Marcus (Brooke), Jason Sweetooth Williams (Mr. Reyes/Jeremy's Dad)
- 09/30/2018 - Off-Broadway - Evening - Will Roland, George Salazar, Stephanie Hsu, Jason Tam, Katlyn Carlson, Lauren Marcus, Gerard Canonico, Tiffany Mann, Britton Smith, Jason Sweettooth Williams. Notes: Tracked; closing night, no speeches were made
- 02/26/2019 - Broadway - tjonc’s master- Will Roland (Jeremy), Troy Iwata (u/s Michael), Gerard Canonico (Rich), Jason Tam (The Squip), Stephanie Hsu (Christine), Katlyn Carlson (Chloe), Tiffany Mann (Jenna), Lauren Marcus (Brooke), Jason Sweetooth Williams (Mr. Reyes/Jeremy's Dad), Britton Smith (Jake)
- 03/27/2019 - Broadway - Matinee - Will Roland (Jeremy Heere), Jason Sweettooth Williams (Mr. Heere/Mr. Reyes/Scary Stockboy), Britton Smith (Jake Dillinger), Katlyn Carlson (Chloe Valentine), Lauren Marcus (Brooke Lohst), Gerard Canonico (Rich Goranski), Stephanie Hsu (Christine Canigula), Tiffany Mann (Jenna Rolan), George Salazar (Michael Mell), Jason Tam (The Squip)